On the morning of July 17, 2005, Michael Jeffries walked somberly through the door of Room 319 of the Augusta County Courthouse. His orange prison suit was bright, and his ankles were fettered to a foot-long chain. Hands together and wrists locked by cold-steel cuffs, Michael paced forward until he reached the seat next to his attorney, Margaret Matthews.
“Good morning.” Margaret said, noticing M...